Trail Off Tuesdays: The Exploding Toads of Hamburg

A peaceful pond, a morning walk, and a horror scene no one expected: toads swelling, twitching, and then bursting along the water’s edge. We follow the 2005 Hamburg mystery from sensational headlines to a grounded, unsettling explanation that blends animal intelligence with fragile biology. What begins as a “Frog Plague” turns into a forensic journey through missing organs, precise wounds, and a defensive reflex gone catastrophically wrong.
 If this curious detour hooked you, subscribe, share the episode with a friend who loves a good mystery, and leave a review, then tell us: do you buy the crow theory?

Transcript

SPEAKER_00: 0:15

Welcome back to Trail of Tuesdays, the little detour where we wander down the strangest paths of history. Today's story takes us to Hamburg, Germany. To a quiet pond that became the scene of one of the most bizarre mysteries ever to ripple through the natural world. It started in the spring of 2005 and for a few extraordinary weeks, toads were exploding. This is the story of the exploding toads of Hamburg. It began near a pond in the Hamburg's Altona district. A peaceful green area surrounded by trees and walking paths where locals would often stroll by the water each morning. But one day in April, they started noticing something strange in their morning walks. Dead toads everywhere. But not just any natural death. The toads had burst. It was like a horror scene. Toad bodies puffed up like balloons and bellies split open with entrails scattered around the edges of the pond. Some horrified witnesses even claimed to see it happen. A toad swelling, twitching, and then pop. Over the course of a few days, over a thousand toads met the same fate. The press quickly gave it a name. The Frog Plague. When the story hit the headlines, it spread like wildfire. Scientists, veterinarians, even paranormal enthusiasts tried to explain it. Some theories made sense, blaming pollution and the chemicals in the water causing the toad's organs to bloat, or potentially a virus or fungal infection, some new amphibian plague. But of course, like with any strange or unusual cases, the stranger theories followed soon enough. From acid rain, aliens, bored teenagers with fireworks. All of them were discussed and debated in newspapers and online forums, each one more outlandish than the last. The only problem with all those theories? Well, there were no signs of burns or poison or even disease. The explosions were described as clean. No one, not even the environmental agencies, had ever seen anything like it. It was like a tiny amphibian apocalypse right in the middle of Hamburg. Finally, in all the madness and the apocalyptical theories, a local vet, Dr. Franz Mushmann, decided to investigate. He began collecting samples of skin, organs, tissues, and studying the remains under a microscope. What he found was strange, to say the least. The toad's livers were missing. But not just missing in the explosion. There were signs they have been cleanly removed. And with no other bite marks on the rest of the body to suggest an animal attack after the explosion, the mystery only deepened. Who or what was stealing toadly verizon Hamburg? So the Toad Watch began. And after days of observation, a theory started to take shape. It was crows. Dr. Mushman realized that crows, which are known for being intelligent and opportunistic birds, had likely discovered a new delicacy. He theorized that they learned to flip the toads onto their backs and peck out specifically the liver, which is known as one of the richest organs in nutrients. He later explained that the toads had identical circular incisions, small enough to match a bird's beak. And once the liver was gone, the toad's natural defense kicked in and they puffed up their bodies with air to look larger when threatened. But without an internal structure to hold the organs in place, the pressure built up, blood vessels ruptured, lungs overexpanded, and the toads literally exploded. When the theory was published, it made international headlines. Many scientists accepted the Crow hypothesis as the best explanation, and even the Guardian, BBC, and National Geographic reported it. But not everyone was entirely convinced. Some scientists argued that there wasn't just enough direct evidence, that no one had actually seen the crows attacking the toads, and that the idea rested mostly on observation of the aftermath. Others pointed out the environmental toxins, parasites, or even fungal infections could have played a role, and that the timing might have simply made the crow theory look like the only answer. Still, most agreed it was the best explanation available. It was a rare glimpse of how animal behavior can intersect with physiology in the strangest way imaginable. The exploding toad mystery had, more or less, been solved. After the cause was revealed, the explosions stopped almost as suddenly as they began. Maybe the crows moved on, or maybe the surviving toads learned faster than we think. Either way, the pond went quiet again, and in the end, it was just nature being clever, messy, and a little explosive. That's it for today's Trail of Tuesdays on the curious case of Hamburg exploding toads. If you enjoyed this story and want more of this curious detours in After the Trail reflections and bonus episodes, come join us on Patreon. It's where the trail keeps going. Until next time, stay safe and stay curious.